Social Strategy
Back To Insights

To Bluesky and Beyond

Whenever you think you’ve mastered the social media game, another platform pops up.

2003? LinkedIn. 2004? Facebook. 2006? Twitter (now X). 2010? Instagram. 2011? Reddit. 2016? TikTok.

And now, Bluesky, Threads, and more…

It might feel like you’re playing a never-ending game of social Whac-A-Mole. But let’s step back. Do you need to be on every platform? And if so, how do you decide whether to be active or claim your handle for safekeeping? The answer depends on your goals, audience, and bandwidth.

Understanding Bluesky and Your Audience

Bluesky operates on an open protocol, giving users greater control over their data and content. This structure offers several distinct advantages:

  • More Autonomy Over What You See: Your content isn’t subject to unpredictable algorithm changes or corporate policies.
  • Flexibility for the Future: Content and connections can move between platforms built on the same protocol, ensuring you aren’t locked into one system.
  • A Focus on Community: Bluesky prioritizes meaningful, respectful interactions.

While Bluesky’s features make it appealing, success depends on understanding where your audience is active. Platforms like Facebook or Instagram may deliver more immediate results if you aim to engage families and students. If your priorities include recruiting staff, showcasing professional achievements, or engaging in education advocacy, LinkedIn may be the most effective platform.

Why Bluesky Might Be the Right Choice

Bluesky arrives as schools reassess their use of platforms like X. Each platform offers unique opportunities, but Bluesky’s simplicity and focus on authentic engagement set it apart.

X (formerly Twitter) has historically been a hub for real-time updates, but its evolving tone and politicization present challenges for schools striving to remain neutral. Maintaining a presence on X may demand time and resources that could be better spent elsewhere.

While seamlessly integrated with Instagram, Threads may feel restrictive for schools seeking a standalone, purpose-built platform for text-based communication.

Bluesky, on the other hand, is streamlined and intentional. Its community-first approach allows schools to focus on engagement without distractions from algorithms.

The Pros and Cons of Being Everywhere

There’s a temptation to be everywhere at once—after all, what if your audience is on a platform you’re ignoring? But spreading yourself too thin can lead to staff burnout and a diluted message.

Pros of Managing Multiple Platforms:

    • Reach diverse audiences.
    • Build visibility across demographics.
    • Adapt to shifting trends quickly.

Cons of Managing Multiple Platforms:

    • Increased workload for your team.
    • Risk of inconsistent messaging.
    • Greater effort is required to maintain meaningful engagement.

We think doing one or two platforms well is better than stretching yourself across five or six and risk losing focus.

How to Start with Bluesky

Bluesky’s simplicity is one of its greatest assets. Joining doesn’t have to be complicated. Here’s how you can get started:

1. Claim Your Handle: Secure your branded name early to maintain consistent branding across platforms.

2. Build a Thoughtful Profile: Use your logo, mission statement, and contact details to create a professional, approachable presence.

3. Start Small and Observe: Watch how other organizations use Bluesky. Begin with posts highlighting achievements or sharing timely updates.

4. Evaluate Engagement: Listen to audience interactions and refine your approach based on what works best.

Pro Tip: Consider a pinned post outlining your main communication channels or setting engagement guidelines (e.g., policies on respectful interactions or blocking users, approved by legal counsel).

Staying Neutral While Communicating Effectively

Decisions about social media platforms should be framed as strategic, not political. If your school reduces activity on X or begins using Bluesky, explain your reasoning to your community.

For example, you might share: “We’re focusing our communication efforts on platforms where we can best connect with our students, families, and community members.” Transparency ensures your decisions are seen as thoughtful and purposeful rather than reactive.

If stepping back from platforms like X, maintain a minimal presence, such as a pinned post directing followers to where you’re actively engaging. This ensures your audience knows where to find you without feeling abandoned.

Bluesky’s emphasis on community and respectful discourse makes it an excellent space for you to maintain neutrality while fostering connections.

Helping Activities and Athletics Centralize Communication

School activities and athletic teams often thrive on platforms like X because of their ability to share real-time updates and connect with fans. However, with X’s popularity waning and its tone becoming increasingly divisive, now is the time to rethink how these groups communicate.

Encourage activities and athletics to shift primary updates to centralized platforms like your school website or athletics management tools. These platforms often include features that go beyond social media, such as:

  • Email Newsletter Sign-Ups: Build a direct line of communication with families and fans.
  • Integrated Calendars: Provide schedules that sync with mobile devices, informing families about events.
  • Real-Time Updates: Share scores and announcements without constant monitoring for appropriateness.

Centralizing updates on feature-rich platforms reduces reliance on external tools while offering families a consistent and reliable experience.

Social platforms thrive on meaningful interaction, not just speed. If the primary reason for using social media is quick updates—“post and done, then move on”—it’s worth considering whether those efforts would be more impactful elsewhere. Centralizing communication simplifies workflows, ensures consistent messaging, and prioritizes clarity over constant churn.

A Strategic Approach to Social Media

Social media decisions aren’t about jumping on trends—they’re about understanding your audience, goals, and resources. Bluesky allows you to focus on meaningful engagement while maintaining your values and efficiency.

By thoughtfully assessing your communication strategies and prioritizing platforms that align with your needs, you can ensure your social media presence is purposeful and impactful.

Published on: January 16, 2025

Topics:

RELATED POSTS